Article: Family seeks police apology

Daytona Beach News-Journal (FL)-May 24, 2008

DAYTONA BEACH – The family of a 17-year-old ordered released from jail Friday after
the second of two felony charges against him were tossed wants an apology from the
police chief and officer who arrested him.

Facing two separate trials on carjacking and home invasion charges, Darious James
Bush had both cases against him dismissed because prosecutor Celeste Gagne
questioned witnesses, who said he wasn’t the person. “I couldn’t go forward because
we don’t have a definite identification,” Gagne said. “I’d be breaching an ethical
duty. The state attorneys have a higher standard than every attorney in the state.
We have to do justice. It doesn’t mean we have to win cases.”

Defense lawyer Brad Sherman credited Gagne with doing the right thing.
But Bush having spent 94 days in jail prompted his family to want an apology,
Sherman said: “The family wants an apology from Detective Nathan Williams and
Chief Chitwood.”

The cases are now being investigated anew, with the focus on a relative with similar
physical features, Gagne said. Police Chief Mike Chitwood stood by his officers and
the investigation.

“They’re not getting an apology from me or (Nathan) Williams,” he said. “We
certainly didn’t go out maliciously target anybody. We acted on information given to
us. We can go only by what a witness tells us.” He said witnesses told officers they
were sure of the identifications of Bush from photo lineups. But Chitwood
acknowledged there can be problems in cases where there is identification of a
suspect from a photo lineup and no physical evidence. “I’ll commend somebody,” he
said. “For stepping up and saying I made a mistake.”

Record Number: 410197843
Copyright, 2008, The News-Journal Corporation

Law Offices of Bradly S. Sherman
Law Office of Attorney Bradley S. Sherman

Phone: 386-532-6000
Fax: 386-532-6002

DeLand Office

105 E Church Street
DeLand, FL 32724
Map and Directions

Law Offices of Bradley S. Sherman serves clients throughout Central Florida, including Orange City, Port Orange, Orlando, Deltona, Daytona Beach, DeBary, New Smyrna Beach, DeLand, Tavares, Clermont, Clearwater, Bunnell, South Daytona, Volusia County, Flagler County, Seminole County, Putnam County, St. Johns County, Polk County, Lake County, Osceola County and Brevard County.

© by Law Offices of Bradley S. Sherman. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Sitemap

visa mastercard discover